Q1 2025 Banking Outlook: Credit Quality & Model Risk

Q1 2025 Banking Outlook: Credit Quality & Model Risk

As community and regional banks enter 2025, the operating environment presents a complex mix of stabilizing interest rates, evolving credit dynamics, and heightened regulatory focus on model risk management. This quarterly outlook examines key trends and priorities for the first quarter.

Economic Environment: Cautious Optimism

Interest Rate Landscape

• Federal funds rate stabilizing after aggressive tightening cycle
• Yield curve dynamics improving but still presenting margin challenges
• Net interest margin pressure persisting for many institutions

Credit Quality Indicators

• Delinquency rates showing selective increases in certain portfolios
• Commercial real estate continues to warrant enhanced monitoring
• Consumer credit performance remains relatively stable but bears watching

Credit Portfolio Focus Areas

Commercial Real Estate (CRE)

CRE remains the most significant credit concern entering 2025:

Office Properties

• Vacancy rates elevated in major metropolitan areas
• Refinancing challenges as loans mature into higher rate environment
• Valuations declining, affecting loan-to-value ratios

Multifamily

• Construction completions exceeding absorption in some markets
• Operating expense increases pressuring cash flows
• Rent growth moderating from pandemic-era peaks

Regulatory Expectations:

• Enhanced CRE concentration monitoring
• Stress testing of CRE portfolios
• Documented mitigation strategies for high-risk segments

Commercial & Industrial (C&I) Lending

Positive Factors:

• Business conditions generally stable
• Employment levels supportive of debt service
• Supply chain disruptions largely resolved

Risk Factors:

• Small business profitability under pressure
• Working capital needs increasing
• Interest rate sensitivity in variable-rate portfolios

Model Risk Management: Q1 2025 Priorities

CECL Model Focus

Regulators continue intensive scrutiny of CECL models as institutions complete their third full year under the standard:

Key Examination Focus Areas:

1. Economic Forecast Selection

   • Reasonableness of forecast period
   • Appropriateness of reversion assumptions
   • Documentation of forecast selection process

2. Qualitative Factor Justification

   • Support for Q-factor magnitudes
   • Consistency with risk environment
   • Avoidance of double-counting with model outputs

3. Model Validation Status

   • Timely completion of annual/biennial validations
   • Adequate response to validation findings
   • Independence of validation function

RegVizion Insight: Institutions should complete Q1 2025 CECL validations early to address findings before peak examination season.

AI/ML Model Governance

The deployment of AI and machine learning models accelerates, bringing heightened regulatory attention:

Q1 Priorities:

• Complete AI/ML model inventory
• Assess fair lending risks in AI credit models
• Enhance AI model documentation
• Implement bias testing protocols

Emerging Concern: Generative AI applications in customer service, fraud detection, and marketing are drawing regulatory questions about risk management and control frameworks.

Regulatory Examination Priorities

Based on recent regulatory guidance and examination trends, Q1 2025 priorities include:

Credit Risk Management

Areas of Focus:

• Loan review program adequacy
• Risk rating system accuracy
• Concentration risk management
• Problem loan identification and management

Heightened Scrutiny:

• CRE portfolios with elevated concentrations
• Agricultural lending in stressed markets
• Indirect auto lending programs

Interest Rate Risk

Despite rate stabilization, IRR remains a supervisory priority:

• Asset-liability management practices
• Interest rate risk modeling
• Contingency funding planning
• Deposit stability assumptions

Cybersecurity and Operational Resilience

Q1 Focus Areas:

• Third-party risk management
• Incident response planning
• Business continuity testing
• Vendor management programs

Strategic Considerations for Q1 2025

1. Credit Policy Review

Early-year credit policy review should address:

• CRE concentration limits and monitoring
• Underwriting standards for challenged sectors
• Risk appetite statements and limits
• Exception reporting and approval processes

2. Allowance Methodology Assessment

CECL allowance methodologies benefit from Q1 recalibration:

• Review historical loss rates for relevance
• Assess qualitative factor appropriateness
• Evaluate economic forecast selections
• Document methodology decisions

3. Model Risk Management Planning

Develop 2025 MRM priorities:

• Schedule model validations
• Plan validator training and development
• Budget for external validation resources
• Enhance model governance processes

4. Technology Investment Decisions

Prioritize technology investments addressing:

• Model risk management platforms
• CECL and allowance tools
• Credit monitoring systems
• Regulatory reporting automation

Opportunity Areas

While challenges persist, Q1 2025 presents opportunities:

Loan Demand Stabilization

• Business investment resuming after rate uncertainty
• Mortgage refinancing activity increasing
• Commercial lending opportunities in quality sponsors

Operational Efficiency

• AI applications improving productivity
• Automation reducing manual processes
• Digital banking adoption continuing

Talent Acquisition

• Experienced professionals available
• Remote work enabling broader recruitment
• Competitive compensation dynamics moderating

Preparing for Q1 Examinations

Institutions facing Q1 examinations should prioritize:

1. Pre-Examination Preparation

   • Complete self-assessments of high-risk areas
   • Update examination document request lists
   • Conduct management pre-examination meetings
   • Review prior examination findings and responses

2. Documentation Enhancement

   • Ensure board meeting minutes reflect key decisions
   • Update risk assessment documentation
   • Verify model validation documentation currency
   • Compile evidence of monitoring activities

3. Issue Remediation

   • Address outstanding examination findings
   • Document remediation efforts comprehensively
   • Prepare management responses to anticipated concerns
   • Establish clear timelines for open items

Outlook: Measured Optimism

Q1 2025 presents both challenges and opportunities for community and regional banks. Credit quality bears close monitoring, particularly in CRE and rate-sensitive portfolios. Model risk management requires sustained focus as AI adoption accelerates and CECL enters its fourth year.

Institutions that proactively address regulatory priorities, strengthen credit risk management, and invest strategically in model governance will be well-positioned for a successful 2025.

The key is maintaining disciplined risk management while capitalizing on lending opportunities in an stabilizing rate environment.

---

Preparing for upcoming examinations or need model validation support? RegVizion provides comprehensive examination preparation, model validation, and credit risk management services. Contact us to discuss your Q1 2025 priorities.